An initial attempt to deride their perceived similarities to other artists - as in trying to sing Tom Petty's "Learning To Fly" lyrics over the "Up All Night" melody - quickly subsided after the first song.
This album was my first proper exposure to The War On Drugs. It's almost impossible not to draw comparisons as you take in a new (to you) band for the first time. The best I can come up with is A Deeper Understanding sounds like that late-great 1980's Bob Dylan album that never existed. The War On Drugs have the uncanny ability to sound both new and familiar.
There is a static nature to the music on A Deeper Understanding that I am finding to be extremely refreshing at this moment in time. The lack of peaks, boldfaced hooks, rousing sing-along choruses, recycled folk-song lyrics and melodies, crazy time-signatures, and key changes keeps the focus on atmosphere throughout its hour-long plus running time.
The lyrics, when you take time to catch them, are effective at conveying the overall mood of the album, which seems to be cautious optimism. The lyrics can also be, at times, inconsequential in a (good) way that blends in and serves the music.
The static consistency I mentioned above does of course have some fluctuation that bubbles out with repeated listens. Melodies and colorings that weren’t obvious at first start to take shape. One gets the impression that these little synth keyboard and vibraphone(?) sounds are very carefully placed.
Sequence matters. Like a lot of albums, A Deeper Understanding leads with what could be said are the best three songs back to back. It could also be said that the uniformity of the remaining songs makes the latter half of the album start to drag.
In actuality, the last 30 or 40 minutes of the album are where it really starts to open up and take form. While songs like "Thinking of A Place" don’t stray too far from the formula, these tracks definitely aren’t trying to be singles and are allowed room to breathe as necessary.
It's been a long, long time since I've heard a new rock album as good as A Deeper Understanding. I think I prefer to start it mid-way through (side 3 if you have it on vinyl) and let it play through to side 2. It's just one big loop.